Monday, January 19, 2009

Screw you, objectivity

Everyone, journalist or citizen (or citizen-journalist), should read this article from the Columbia Journalism Review. Author Brent Cunningham outlines the flaws in the "objectivity" paradigm that American journalists hold to. Here are some of his strongest points:
  • The objective standard makes reporters lazy; it is easy to find two official perspectives on an issue and harder to find out what is actually going on.
  • Nobody is unbiased, so the rule of objectivity asks for dishonesty.
  • The Society of Professional Journalists stopped including objectivity in their code of ethics in 1996.
  • Newspapers in the mid-19th-century adopted objective journalism not as an ethical standard, but as a business practice to draw a wider range of readers.
  • Avoiding bias is often avoiding the more crucial role of journalists in a society; to dig deep into controversial issues and undermine the status quo.
This is a scary time for journalists in terms of job security, but let's face it: A media overhaul has been long time coming. Journalists are supposed to be society's eyes and ears, and we have essentially been blind and deaf for the last decade-- all because reporters were afraid of Anne Coulter calling them out on liberal bias. The article also reminded me of a Poynter link I posted earlier today about changing ethical standards. Basically, I agree with Cunningham. I'm biased, and that's the point. 

2 comments:

  1. I like your point about objectivity making reporters lazy. I definitely agree that it's harder to find out the truth then to find out two people's versions of the truth. That being said what a reporter says is the truth is just another version of what could be the truth. I think that articles should just include as many reasonable opinions as possible include the writer's.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think you are so right. I really like what you said here: "Journalists are supposed to be society's eyes and ears, and we have essentially been blind and deaf for the last decade-- all because reporters were afraid of Anne Coulter calling them out on liberal bias." I think it is time for journalist's to stop being afraid and dare to be honest about how they see things (like you are doing...)

    ReplyDelete